Piano Concerto № 1 d-Minor op. 15 (1858)
Rondo: Allegro non troppo
Sándor Falvai, pianist
Hungarian National Philharmonic Orchestra
Zoltán Kocsis, conductor
Trois odes funèbres S. 112 (1860-1866)
Les Morts – Oraison
Le triomphe funèbre du Tasse
Hungarian National Philharmonic Orchestra
Zoltán Kocsis, conductor
Eine Eckart Rahn Produktion
Celestial Harmonies 14333-2
Recorded June 13-17, July 20, 2016 in Budapest
Photo: László Kenéz
Franz Liszt and his Trois odes funèbres:
A Philosophy of Art, Poetry and Religion
Download the complete thesis by Jennifer L. Hund-King here:
On 23 August 1874 Franz Liszt wrote a letter to his former secretary, the composer Peter Cornelius: “For a long time I’ve had a couple of manuscripts finished that I would like to send to Schott for publication. Yet I fear that they will lie about there unread. The very title, Three Symphonic Funeral Odes (Trois Odes funèbres symphoniques) will probably frighten them off; moreover, the full scores, each roughly twenty pages long, would have to appear simultaneously with the piano transcriptions (for two or four hands).”
Liszt had sized up the situation correctly: of the Trois odes funèbres he composed between 1860 and 1866, only the third, Le triomphe funèbre du Tasse, was published during his lifetime both in full score and a piano version, albeit not by Schott, but by Breitkopf & Härtel. Of the other two odes, Les morts and La notte, he would only witness the publication of a piano version of La notte (Schott, 1883). It was not until three decades after his death that Les morts and the orchestral version of La notte finally appeared in print.
One reason for the convoluted publication history of the Odes was probably the fact that none of them fit easily into the image of an autonomous and self-contained work of art. This is primarily due to the fact that each exists in several conflicting versions. Not only does each of the three Odes have arrangements for solo piano and piano duet in addition to its orchestral version, there is also an organ version of Les morts, one for violin and piano of La notte, and a two-piano arrangement (admittedly lost) of Le triomphe funèbre du Tasse. In several cases it is almost impossible to tell what is temporary and what is definitive, or which is the original and which the arrangement. Further, La notte is a paraphrase of an earlier piano piece (Il Pensieroso from the Italian volume of the Années de pèlerinage), and Le triomphe funèbre du Tasse is an epilogue to Liszt’s second symphonic poem, Tasso: Lamento e trionfo. The latter Ode in particular is almost unintelligible without a reference to the symphonic poem of several years earlier. All the same, it is precisely this lack of independence, this need for a larger frame of reference, that constitutes the unifying feature of the Three Odes. Each turns on the central idea of recollection and reminiscence. In the second and third Odes the reminiscence is purely musical: both recall an earlier composition. In the case of Les morts, however, the reminiscence is extra-musical: it recalls not only the deceased in general, but specifically Liszt’s son Daniel, who had died only a few months before Liszt embarked on the composition.
Composed in 1860, Les morts is based on the like-named oraison (prayer) by the French priest, poet, and philosopher Félicité de Lamennais. Liszt made use of only the first three and the longer final stanza of this eight-stanza prose-poem. Rather than prefixing the words to the score in the customary manner, however, he entered them directly into the score above the music, thereby making it patently clear just how closely his music relates to the poem. Nonetheless, all the evidence suggests that he never intended the piece to be performed with the words declaimed simultaneously in the manner of a melodrama. Only fragments of Lamennais’ text in Latin translation are sung by a male choir, which was not added until 1866. The choir sings Beati mortui qui in Domino moriuntur at the end of each stanza as well as the dialogue from the final stanza, De profundis clamavi or Te Deum laudamus. Structurally, the addition of the choir further underscores what was already true of the purely instrumental version – namely, that the music is very closely aligned on the text. The four stanzas, with their textually identical conclusions, are faithfully reflected in the music and merely flanked by a few bars of introduction and conclusion at the beginning and end of the piece. At the same time, however, they evolve from a process of variation to one resembling thematic development. If the second stanza is an overt variation of the first, the relation between the second and third is limited to the incisive principal rhythm. The fourth stanza opens with a genuine passage of development that leads to a climax beginning in m. 100.
The second ode, La notte, was composed from 1863 to 1866. As mentioned above, it is based on a piano piece from the Années de pèlerinage, namely, on Il Pensieroso, whose dirge-like rhythms make it the darkest piece in the Italian cycle. The title refers to the like-named statue of Lorenzo de’ Medici that Michelangelo created for his tomb in the Medici Chapel in Florence. At the same time, however, the score is also preceded by a quatrain by Michelangelo himself that relates not to Il Pensieroso, but to a different statue in the Medici Chapel: the image of a sleeping woman, the Allegory of the Night (La Notte), from a group of sculptures on the tomb of Giuliano de’ Medici. The same poem is also prefixed to the score of La notte, but in this case the connection is made explicit by the title of the sculpture, La Notte. In La notte the dirge-like gesture of Il Pensieroso is elaborated into a complete stylized funeral march. A brief introduction is followed by a virtually complete orchestrated version of the piano piece that largely adheres to the original. A newly composed transition leads to a completely new central section in A major noteworthy for its striking Magyarisms, especially the “Hungarian” cadences. The piece ends with a varied recapitulation of the A section.
The relation between the third ode, Le triomphe funèbre du Tasse, and the symphonic poem to which it forms an epilogue is much less rigorous. The only musical link is the opening four bars of the Tasso theme from the symphonic poem, which is quoted verbatim in mm. 92-95 and included with slight variations elsewhere. The program underlying the symphonic poem is summarized in Liszt’s preface as “the great antithesis of the genius, unrecognized in Life, but bathed in a radiant nimbus in Death.” Thus the narrative impetus, which is projected in Tasso using an ingenious fusion of single-movement sonata-allegro form and four-movement sonata cycle, is the typically nineteenth-century passage per aspera ad astra – from darkness to light. Being an epilogue, Le triomphe funèbre du Tasse comes, one might say, after the story of the symphonic poem is over. Consequently it does not outline a narrative trajectory: themes and motifs evoking lamentation, triumph, and solace stand side by side throughout the piece. An introduction with a chromatic motif (mm. 1-20) is followed by the presentation of three themes or motivic groups: a triumphant variant of the Tasso theme in D-flat major (mm. 21-40), a contrasting theme of distinctive lyric urgency in A major (mm. 41-69), and a succession of motifs signifying lamentation (mm. 70-91). A reappearance of the Tasso theme, this time sotto voce in E minor (mm. 92-107), is followed by a melodious central section (mm. 108-139) that modulates from E-flat major via G minor and A major to a triumphant transformation of the second theme in F major (mm. 140-68). This transformation is in turn followed by a recapitulation of the Tasso theme in A-flat major (mm. 169-91) and by the motifs of lamentation (mm. 192-206). A brief transition leads to a coda (mm. 212-45) that is especially remarkable for its opening harmonies as F-major, A-major and D-major triads alternate above an F tonic pedal in the bass that is garlanded with chromatic neighbor-notes at one-measure intervals.
Steven Vande Moortele